Tasting Time! An In-Depth Look into Unfiltered vs. Filtered EVOO

Extra Virgin Olive Oil (EVOO) is a valuable and healthy cooking oil, offering an array of culinary and wellness benefits. From rich flavor to high nutritional value, it's a kitchen essential. Yet not all EVOO is created equal. Understanding how filtering affects the taste and nutrition of EVOO can make all the difference to your food and your health!

The process of filtering is a critical part of EVOO production, but it often goes overlooked by consumers. In this article, we'll explore the differences between filtered and unfiltered EVOO and what it means for your cooking and nutrition.

We'll cover the following topics: 

  • What is EVOO? 
  • What is filtering? 
  • Benefits of unfiltered EVOO
  • Benefits of filtered EVOO 
  • Tasting tips 
  • Food safety considerations

To understand the differences between filtered and unfiltered EVOO, let's begin by exploring the basics.

EVOO is made from the first press of olives and is therefore considered the highest quality of olive oil. It has a lower acidity than other grades of olive oil, and a much more distinct, fruity flavor and aroma. Because of its high quality, EVOO can be used for frying, baking, and even drizzling over dishes.

But what about filtering? Filtering is a process used to remove impurities, such as sediment and plant debris, from the oil before it’s bottled. It can also help to remove some of the olive oil’s more pungent flavors, resulting in a milder, more consistent product.

However, there are pros and cons to filtering EVOO. While filtering can enhance the flavor and aroma, it can also reduce the oil’s health benefits, including its antioxidant power. As we'll explore further, this can make a big difference on your plate and in your body.

So, what are the key differences between filtered and unfiltered EVOO? Let's find out.

A Look at Unfiltered EVOO

Have you ever seen a bottle of olive oil with the words “Unfiltered EVOO” printed on its label? Unfiltered EVOO is extra virgin olive oil that has been left in its purest form, as opposed to filtered which goes through an additional filtering process. The difference between the two isn't just a cosmetic one—it's also one of flavor, benefits, and cost.

So what makes unfiltered EVOO so special?

First and foremost, it's the taste. Unfiltered oils are kept in their most natural state and tend to contain more flavor molecules than filtered versions. This intense flavor profile comes with a wide range of health benefits—unfiltered EVOO contains beneficial compounds like polyphenols that may help protect your heart and reduce inflammation. Plus, since it hasn’t gone through any additional filtration processes or added artificial flavors or acids, unfiltered EVOO has a longer shelf life.

Of course, picking out quality unfiltered EVO can be tricky for the untrained palate — which is why you need to know how to determine the quality of an unfiltered olive oil before you buy:

  • Check the press date — Always pick oils that have been cold-pressed within 12 months
  • Smell before you buy — Unfiltered oil should have a light fruity fragrance with little to no bitterness
  • Look at clarity — Cloudy oils are better than clear ones because they haven’t been reprocessed by chemicals or heat
  • Taste test — If you can’t try before buying, look up reviews online from reputable sources to make sure it wouldn’t be too bitter for your tastes

Overall, knowing how to differentiate between filtered and unfiltered extra virgin olive oil can make your cooking experience much more enjoyable and flavorful—and if you take the time to learn how to identify quality unfiltered EVOOs in stores or online, you won't end up shelling out extra money for something that doesn't pass your taste test.

The Filtering Process: Benefits & Drawbacks

When it comes to Extra Virgin Olive Oil (EVOO), there are two main types—filtered and unfiltered. Each type of oil has its own unique flavor and nutritional value, but they go through two very different processes to reach their final state.

Let’s take a look at the differences between filtered and unfiltered EVOO, and what benefits and drawbacks are associated with each.

The Filtering Process

The filtering process for EVOO involves taking the oil through a series of filters. These filters remove particles like sediment and other impurities, resulting in a clear and transparent oil that is free of any visible residue. The different types of filters used range from stainless steel, paper, or felt, to ceramic, and even glass. The choice of filter used will depend on the type of oil being filtered, as well as the desired end result.

Pros & Cons of Filtered vs Unfiltered

The most significant difference between filtered and unfiltered oil is their respective flavor and nutrient profile. Unfiltered oil has a stronger, more pungent flavor, in addition to having higher levels of antioxidants and other beneficial nutrients. On the other hand, filtered oil has a milder flavor, and lower levels of antioxidants and other beneficial compounds.

One of the major benefits of filtered oil is a longer shelf life. Since the filtering process removes impurities and particles, the oil stays fresher for longer, and is less prone to oxidation and spoilage. Additionally, the clear and transparent appearance of filtered oil can be aesthetically pleasing and add a little extra flare to dishes.

However, one potential drawback of filtered oil is that it often requires the use of chemical solvents to break down the sediments and other impurities that are being filtered out. This process can result in the oil losing some of its natural flavor, as well as some of its nutritional value.

Tasting Time! An In-Depth Look at Unfiltered vs Filtered Extra Virgin Olive Oils

Are you looking to buy the tastiest extra virgin olive oil (EVOO) and can't decide between filtered or unfiltered? Well, look no further—it's time for a deep dive into the world of EVOO tasting!

First things first, if you want to get the most out of your experience, you need to make sure you're buying quality EVOO. To do this, carefully inspect the bottle label before making your purchase and look for phrases like “cold-pressed”, “unfiltered” or “first cold press”. Avoid any bottles with vague labels that don't specify how it was processed or what type of oil it is.

Once you have your EVOOs at home, it's time to start tasting!

Here are some tips on analyzing and appreciating the differences between different types of extra virgin olive oil:

  • Taste both oils side by side — Start by evaluating basic characteristics like color, viscosity, taste and smell
  • Sip & swish — Take small sips of each oil in your mouth and swish them around to truly appreciate their texture and flavor
  • Look for clues — Small differences like aftertaste can tell you a lot about which type of EVOO is right for you

Now that you've tasted both oils and evaluated their individual properties, it's time to put these results into perspective.

When comparing filtered vs unfiltered extra virgin olive oil, there are several key differences to look out for:

  • Unfiltered EVOO tends to be more flavorful because it contains more beneficial compounds
  • Unfiltered EVOO may contain sediment which gives it a cloudy appearance compared to filtered versions
  • Quality unfiltered EVOO also has a longer shelf life than filtered

Finally, here's a little-known secret about EVOO tasting: Try adding a few drops to plain water! This simple experiment will help you determine whether an olive oil is fresh—if it turns solid and falls to the bottom of the glass over time instead of dispersing throughout the liquid then your oil has gone bad!

Conclusion

We've learned a lot about the differences between unfiltered and filtered EVOO. It all comes down to different types of flavor and health benefits. When it comes to flavor, unfiltered EVOO has a grassier, peppery flavor, while filtered EVOO tends to be milder and smoother.

In terms of health benefits, unfiltered EVOO is packed with antioxidants and polyphenols that can reduce inflammation and even lower cholesterol, while filtered EVOO still provides some nutritional value but not as much as unfiltered EVOO.

So, if you want a more complex flavor profile, unfiltered EVOO is for you. But if you want to get more of the health benefits, you should go for unfiltered EVOO.

Now that you know more about the differences between unfiltered and filtered EVOO, here are some tips to help you choose the right one for your needs:

  • Make sure you check the label before buying to make sure you're getting the type of EVOO you want. 
  • Taste test them both to find out which tastes better to you. 
  • You can use both types of EVOO in different dishes, depending on the flavor you want. For example, use unfiltered EVOO in salad dressings or pesto sauces for a richer flavor, and use filtered EVOO in baking or frying for milder flavor. 
  • Always store your EVOO in a cool dark place to maintain its freshness.

No matter which types of EVOO you choose, it's sure to make your dishes delicious and nutritious! So next time you go to the store, make sure to taste the difference between unfiltered and filtered EVOO and choose the one that suits your needs best.

Back to blog

Leave a comment